Shop 11, 59 Brisbane Rd,
Redbank QLD 4301
Monday—Friday
8am—4pm

Beware of this uncommon and dangerous ankle sprain…

Most of us have rolled our ankles at some joint. Ankle sprains are one of the most common injuries in everyday life — whether you’re playing sport, hiking on an uneven surface, or simply stepping off the sidewalk at the wrong angle. In most cases, a sprained ankle heals with time, rest, and some basic management. But not all ankle sprains are the same.

There’s one specific type of ankle sprain that requires far more attention than the rest. If it’s managed poorly, it can even have serious long-term consequences for your mobility and quality of life. I’m talking about the high ankle sprain, also known as a syndesmosis ankle sprain. This is a dangerous ankle sprain that’s often missed or mistaken for a more straightforward lateral ankle sprain. The case study below is a prime example of what can go wrong when it isn’t identified early.

Case Study: Poor Management of an Ankle Sprain

The history: 

A woman in her early thirties sustained an ankle injury after losing her footing stepping off a sidewalk. Initially, the injury appeared to be a typical ankle sprain. She applied basic RICE principles — rest, ice, compression, and elevation — and waited for improvement.

After two weeks with no real change in her symptoms, she visited her GP. An X-ray was performed, which ruled out a broken bone, and she was given pain medication and advised to rest. However, her ankle pain continued to worsen rather than improve.

By the four-week mark, she sought a physiotherapy consultation — and this is where the picture became much clearer.

The examination:

  • The ankle joint felt unstable with increased laxity on testing
  • She was unable to pivot on her affected foot due to pain
  • Difficulty bearing weight and walking on the lower leg
  • Decreased balance on the affected foot
  • Significant tenderness directly over the middle of the ankle — a hallmark sign of a syndesmotic injury
  • Positive results on key physiotherapy stress tests, including the side-to-side test, external rotation test, and weight-bearing lunge test

The treatment:

An immediate referral to a new GP triggered a cascade of appropriate intervention:

  • Emergency X-ray and MRI confirmed a syndesmosis injury with tibiofibular diastasis — a separation of the two leg bones that had been missed entirely on initial presentation
  • Referral to an orthopaedic specialist
  • Urgent surgery to stabilise the ankle joint
  • Post-surgical referral to physiotherapy for rehabilitation

Ankle Sprain: Syndesmosis

For the more astute clinicians or health practitioners, many would know that I’m immediately referring to a syndesmosis injury – otherwise known as a high ankle sprain. This case was poorly managed, as the follow-up with the doctor should have included further investigation. Especially because the ankle pain wasn’t resolving. Usually, seeking out a physiotherapist before a doctor is beneficial for most simple ankle sprains.

Unfortunately for this individual, had the right assessments been completed and monitored over weeks, a surgery would have been avoided. With prompt and correct management — including a thorough physical examination and appropriate imaging — this individual would have recovered in a much shorter timeframe and returned to her daily gym and sport routine without the need for surgical intervention. This case is a strong reminder of why high ankle sprains must not be managed like a traditional ankle sprain.

Epidemiological data suggests as many as 1-2 out of 10 people will suffer a syndesmosis ankle sprain (Williams & Allen, 2010). Although it’s an injury that largely occurs in athletic populations, there have been many cases – like the one above – where syndesmosis injuries happen in everyday life.

The Basics: Anatomy

The syndesmosis joint is made up of several key structures that work together to maintain ankle stability:

  • The distal tibia and fibula — the two leg bones that form the top of the ankle joint
  • The interosseous tibiofibular ligament — the syndesmosis itself, connecting the fibula and tibia together
  • The anterior inferior tibiofibular ligament (AITFL) — one of the most commonly injured ligaments in a high ankle sprain
  • The posterior inferior tibiofibular ligament (PITFL)
  • The transverse tibiofibular ligament (TTFL)

In a syndesmosis sprain, the primary concern is the connection between the two shin bones — the tibia and fibula — being pushed apart. Disruption of the injured ligaments holding these leg bones together causes excessive movement and instability through the ankle joint. This is extremely detrimental to all aspects of daily life, including walking, running, climbing stairs, and any form of lower limb exercise.

It’s important to stay away from excessive weight-bearing and activities that provoke pain during recovery, as this allows the damaged ligaments to heal back into their natural position. Long-term complications — including chronic ankle instability, recurrent ankle sprains, chronic pain, and loss of strength and range of motion — can all arise if syndesmosis injuries are not treated properly.

Common Signs of a High Ankle Sprain

  • Mechanism of injury: a forceful external rotation of the ankle, where the knee turns outward relative to the foot — the classic external rotation mechanism of a syndesmotic ankle sprain
  • Swelling around the middle and outer edges of the ankle
  • Tenderness directly over the middle of the ankle, rather than on the outside of the ankle as seen in a typical lateral ankle sprain
  • Positive physiotherapy stress tests, including the external rotation test, fibular translation test, and squeeze test

The following symptoms are indicators that you should have your ankle assessed as soon as possible by a qualified health professional:

  • Pain that increases when your knees go past your toes — for example, when lunging or climbing stairs
  • Pain with pivoting on the affected foot
  • Your ankle feels loose, unstable, or like the two bones are shifting
  • Inability to point your toes fully
  • Unable to put full weight on the ankle

Timeline for Recovery for the Syndesmosis Ankle Sprain

The following guidelines for recovery are based on the recommendations suggested by Williams & Allen (2010). These are only ‘guidelines’ and do not reflect the recovery that you or anyone else may experience. A host of individual factors can influence the speed in which you recover back to your baseline and must be considered in any injury.

First 6 weeks – Protecting the Ankle

  • A moon boot (removable walking boot) and/or crutches to reduce weight-bearing and protect the ankle joint
  • Gentle ankle movement exercises to avoid stiffness — within a pain-free range
  • Prevention of re-injury, particularly on uneven surfaces
  • Pain management, including medication, ice or heat therapy, and gentle massage

Progress to the next stage when: you are able to fully bear weight on the affected leg and manage stairs and uneven ground with minimal discomfort.

6 – 12 weeks – Normalising walking and movement

  • Gait retraining to restore a normal walking pattern
  • Calf and foot strengthening exercises to rebuild support around the ankle joint
  • Balance exercises such as single-leg stands and tandem stance to retrain proprioception
  • Ankle stretches and range of motion exercises — always pain-free

Progress to the next stage when: hopping and light running produce minimal discomfort.

12 weeks + Return to sport or hobbies

  • Reintroduce lateral plane movements and direction changes
  • Begin gentle sport-specific activities such as agility drills and controlled training drills
  • Steady-state conditioning including jogging, running, and jumping rope

Steadily build your fitness and ankle strength, and progressively advance sport-specific activities. Return to full sport-level activity is appropriate when you can train pain-free and with minimal discomfort across all movement planes.

Caution Signs: 

A few warning signs to be wary of include:

  • Unable to put any weight on your ankle
  • Feeling severe pins and needles in your feet
  • Severe pain that is intolerable

If you experience any of these, go to the emergency department or your local GP immediately. During this stage, it is essential to rule out an ankle fracture — a broken bone left undiagnosed will have serious long-term consequences for your recovery.

This specific ankle injury can potentially have serious consequences on your long-term ankle function. If you are unsure about the severity of your ankle sprain, please seek professional advice — including a consultation with our physiotherapy team, who can assess the ankle joint, perform the appropriate stress tests, and refer you for further imaging if needed.

Conclusion

The purpose of this post is to make you aware that a more serious type of ankle sprain exists. A syndesmosis ankle sprain — or high ankle sprain — cannot be managed like a usual lateral ankle sprain, takes considerably longer to heal, and carries a genuine risk of long-term complications if it isn’t identified and treated correctly.

The main messages to take away: contact a medical professional if you exhibit any of the caution signs above, if your ankle pain is not improving after a week or two of basic management, or if you are concerned about the nature of your sprain. And if something doesn’t feel right, trust that instinct and get it properly assessed.

Like any injury, syndesmosis sprains can heal. But proper management and a structured rehabilitation program are essential to ensure a favourable outcome. The earlier the right care begins, the better.

References

  • Bleakley, C. M., McDonough, S. M., & MacAuley, D. C. (2008). Some conservative strategies are effective when added to controlled mobilisation with external support after acute ankle sprain: a systematic review. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy, 54(1), 7 – 20.
  • Physiopedia. (2020). Tibiofibular Diatasis. https://www.physio-pedia.com/Tibiofibular_Diastasis
  • Williams, G. N., & Allen, E. J. (2010). Rehabilitation of Syndesmotic (High) Ankle Sprains. Sports Health, 2(6), 460 – 470.

See other related articles

Uncategorized

4 steps to diagnose and get rid of your lower back pain now

Uncategorized

4 step guide to begin fixing your knee arthritis now!

Uncategorized

The Bizarre Truth About Your MRI for Your Lower Back Pain

Uncategorized

4 steps to diagnose and get rid of your lower back pain now

Uncategorized

4 step guide to begin fixing your knee arthritis now!

Uncategorized

The Bizarre Truth About Your MRI for Your Lower Back Pain